Britain announced sweeping reforms to its asylum system on Saturday, revealing plans to make refugee status temporary and extend the route to permanent settlement from five years to 20 years — a fourfold increase that marks one of the most significant policy overhauls in decades.
The Labour government, under increasing pressure from the rising Reform UK party, has progressively tightened its immigration policies, particularly on irregular migration across the English Channel. Officials say the changes aim to deter new arrivals and address public concerns that have reshaped the national political debate.
According to the Home Office, the new framework draws heavily from Denmark’s stringent model — a system often cited by European governments leaning toward tougher immigration controls but widely criticised by human rights organisations. Central to the UK’s proposed approach is the introduction of temporary refugee protection, which will be reassessed regularly and can be revoked if an individual’s home country is deemed safe.
A major component of the reform involves removing the legal duty to provide state-funded accommodation and allowances for certain asylum seekers.
The Home Office said support would be withdrawn from individuals who are capable of working but choose not to, as well as those who commit criminal offences. Resources, it added, would instead be focused on asylum seekers who contribute economically and socially to local communities.
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood explained the shift in an interview with Sky News, saying that the UK’s current settlement rules are “far more generous” than many European systems. Under the proposed changes, refugee status would be reviewed every two-and-a-half years, and the path to permanent residency would be extended to 20 years. “We will change that,” she said, arguing that a more rigorous review system is necessary.
Mahmood said further details would be announced Monday, including plans concerning Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to family life. While the government intends to remain within the ECHR, it says the interpretation of Article 8 has obstructed the removal of people who no longer qualify to stay in the country.
The reforms have triggered an immediate backlash.
More than 100 British charities issued a joint letter urging Mahmood to end what they called “scapegoating of migrants” and warned that punitive policies risk fuelling racism and public hostility. They argued that asylum seekers are being pushed further into uncertainty and marginalisation.
Immigration has become the leading issue for British voters, even surpassing the economy, according to recent polls. Tensions have escalated over the summer, with protests erupting outside hotels housing asylum seekers at state expense.
Home Office data shows that 109,343 people applied for asylum in the UK in the year ending March 2025 — a 17% increase from the previous year and slightly above the historic peak recorded in 2002.
Despite the crackdown, the government says it intends to expand “safe and legal” pathways for people fleeing conflict or persecution, with Mahmood arguing that Britain must continue to offer protection to those in genuine need.
The UK’s new system aims to mirror — and in some cases exceed — the restrictive policies used in Denmark and other European nations.
Denmark grants refugees temporary residence permits, typically lasting two years, requiring renewal upon expiry. Authorities can revoke protection if conditions in the refugee’s home country improve, and citizenship now requires a longer period of residency. Danish officials say the model has led to a dramatic reduction in asylum claims and a high rate of deportations for rejected applicants.
Rights advocates, however, argue that Denmark’s approach has created a hostile environment that leaves refugees in prolonged limbo. Britain’s Refugee Council echoed this criticism, noting on X that people fleeing danger do not compare asylum systems; instead, they seek places where they have language familiarity, family connections, or communities that can help them rebuild their lives.
Leave a comment